From 2016 to 2018, Creech was a top player on the Philadelphia Phantomz, twice earning All-American honors. In 2019, she was the league leader in interceptions (12), interception return yards (295), and interception return touchdowns (5), while also ranking in the top five for pass deflections and kickoff return yardage. Her stellar performance earned her a third All-American selection. Creech was a standout basketball player at James B. Hunt High School in Wilson, N.C., and a collegiate basketball player at Goldey-Beacom College.